The insurer helped me find a specialist, then denied the claim as out-of-network. What now?
Make two arguments together. Reliance: the insurer's own representative directed you, so ask for the call record and hold them to it. Network adequacy: if no in-network specialist exists within the plan's access standard, ask for a network gap exception at in-network cost sharing, applied to this claim.
What to do, in order
- Step 1
Get the call record
Ask the insurer in writing for the date, time and reference of the call where you were given the provider's name, and for the recording or notes. Insurers keep them; a written request stops the record being lost.
- Step 2
Document the network gap
List the in-network specialists of that type you checked and their distances, against the plan's access standard (distance or travel time by specialty). Ask for the standard by name.
- Step 3
Ask for a retroactive gap exception
Write that no in-network specialist was available within the standard and that the insurer's representative directed you to this provider; ask for the claim to be reprocessed at in-network benefits under the plan's network adequacy provision.
- Step 4
Bring the specialist in
A letter from the specialist that no closer in-network provider offers the service, with an offer to accept in-network rates for this episode, often settles it.
The deadline that applies
The appeal window in the denial notice, at least 180 days on ERISA and ACA plans (29 CFR 2560.503-1; 45 CFR 147.136). State network-adequacy complaints to the insurance department can be filed alongside the appeal for insured plans. The letter controls.
Calculate your date →Documents to gather
- The denial or EOB
- Your written request for the call record, and the insurer's reply
- Your list of in-network specialists checked, with distances
- The plan's access standard, once provided
- The specialist's letter
Go deeper
Related questions
Will reliance alone win the appeal?
It is stronger with the call record and weaker without it. Pair it with the gap-exception argument.
What counts as no in-network specialist?
The plan's own access standard, usually a distance or travel-time limit by specialty. Ask for it in writing.
Does this work on a self-funded plan?
The plan document governs instead of state rules, but most self-funded plans carry a gap-exception provision. Ask for it by name.
Sources
Upload the denial letter. A senior reviewer reads it within 24 hours and tells you in writing whether it can be appealed and how. $0 upfront, 10% of what is recovered, nothing if we do not recover. Not a law firm.
Start a free denial review →